Healthcare sharing ministries are popular in Utah, particularly among LDS communities and those seeking lower monthly costs. They are not insurance. Before joining one, understand exactly what you're getting — and what you're not.
Free, no-obligation — a licensed Utah agent will reach out within one business day.
A licensed Utah broker will contact you within one business day. Your information is never sold. No cost, no obligation.
What They Are
Healthcare sharing ministries (HCSMs) are organizations where members share each other's medical costs based on shared religious or ethical beliefs. Members pay a monthly "share amount" (similar to a premium) into a pool, and when a member has a medical need, other members' shares are used to pay the bill. They are specifically exempted from ACA insurance regulations.
In Utah, HCSMs are particularly prevalent due to the state's large religiously observant population. Several national organizations — including Sedera, Liberty HealthShare, Samaritan Ministries, and Christian Healthcare Ministries — operate in Utah, as do some LDS-affiliated or faith-compatible programs.
Monthly share amounts are typically lower than ACA premiums — particularly for healthy individuals — which drives their appeal. A family of four might pay $500–$700/month in HCSM shares versus $1,200–$1,800/month for an unsubsidized ACA Gold plan. However, this comparison often ignores the fundamental differences in what each provides.
• Pre-existing conditions: most HCSMs exclude them entirely or impose lengthy waiting periods (often 1–5 years)
• No guarantee of payment — the ministry can decline to share any claim
• No state oversight or appeals process
• May not count as "minimum essential coverage" for tax purposes
• Bills are often sent directly to providers who may not accept sharing as payment
Healthcare sharing is potentially appropriate for healthy adults with no significant pre-existing conditions, low healthcare utilization, alignment with the ministry's religious or ethical values, strong emergency funds to self-cover denied claims, and a clear understanding of the risks involved. They are rarely appropriate for families with children, anyone with chronic conditions, or those without significant financial reserves.
The Alternative
Before choosing a healthcare sharing ministry over an ACA plan, a broker will calculate your net ACA cost after subsidies. Many Utahns who believe they can't afford ACA coverage qualify for plans that cost less than or comparable to HCSM shares — with legal payment guarantees and regulatory protection that sharing ministries cannot provide.
A licensed Utah broker calculates your ACA net cost after subsidies — often surprisingly close to or less than healthcare sharing shares, with legal protections sharing can't provide.
Find a Utah Broker →